In today’s fast-paced business world, background checks have become a crucial part of the hiring process. They ensure that potential employees are qualified, trustworthy, and fit for the roles they’re being considered for. However, when choosing a background check service, small businesses must navigate a maze of options, each with its costs and benefits. One such service is HireRight, a popular choice for employers seeking affordable and reliable background screening.
However, while HireRight’s pricing structure may seem appealing to small businesses, many Reddit users who have shared their experiences paint a very different picture. Complaints about long processing times, excessive documentation requests, and rising costs have led to widespread dissatisfaction with the service. So, what’s the real story behind HireRight’s small business costs? Let’s dive into this topic, taking a closer look at both the opportunities and challenges HireRight presents to small businesses.
So, What Exactly Is Hireright?
Before diving deeper into users’ experiences and the costs associated with HireRight, let’s first take a step back and understand what this company actually offers. HireRight is a background check provider that businesses use to verify potential hires’ employment history, criminal records, education, and other important details. It’s commonly used by employers looking to streamline their hiring process while ensuring that the people they bring into their organizations are trustworthy.

HireRight is often chosen for its relatively low cost compared to other background screening companies, making it an attractive option for small businesses that must stay within tight budgets. The company offers a variety of background check packages, including criminal background checks, employment history verification, education verification, and drug testing.
Now, You Might Be Wondering, Why Is This So Important?
Background checks are vital for maintaining organizational safety, compliance, and efficiency. For small businesses, these checks help mitigate the risk of hiring individuals who might not be as qualified or trustworthy as they appear on paper. This process helps to ensure that only the most qualified candidates are brought into the fold, contributing to a smoother work environment and better business operations.
For small business owners, the need for an affordable background screening option is real. Small businesses don’t have the same resources as larger corporations to spend on extensive background checks or in-house HR departments. In this context, HireRight’s pricing model offers a budget-friendly solution. However, as we’ll see, affordability comes with challenges that some business owners and candidates find troubling.
On One Hand, This Opens Up Exciting Possibilities…
The affordability of HireRight’s services can open up exciting possibilities for small businesses. Background checks are a necessary investment, but hiring a third-party service to handle them can save time and energy. Small businesses, often stretched thin with limited resources, can benefit from the convenience of using a service like HireRight, which allows them to outsource the usually tedious and time-consuming process of verifying job candidates.
Additionally, HireRight offers a variety of plans that can suit businesses of all sizes. The company’s ability to cater to small businesses with tailored packages makes it an attractive choice. The pricing is competitive, and many companies report that HireRight’s services are generally easy to navigate from an employer’s perspective.
But, Like Any Opportunity, This Comes With Its Own Set Of Challenges:
Unfortunately, many users on Reddit have shared that using HireRight comes with significant challenges, especially for small businesses. While the pricing might be attractive, the service quality often leaves much to be desired. Let’s examine some users’ main complaints and concerns about HireRight.
Lengthy Processing Times:
One of Reddit users’ most common complaints is the long processing times for background checks. While some background check companies can complete the process in a matter of days, HireRight is often criticized for taking weeks to finalize a report. This delay can be a dealbreaker for small businesses trying to hire quickly, as it can delay the onboarding process and lead to missed opportunities.
Delays in background checks can also lead to anxiety for candidates, especially if they’re waiting for a job offer to be finalized. In some cases, job offers have even been jeopardized due to the delays in processing. This affects the candidate and the small business, which risks losing a qualified candidate due to inefficiency.
Excessive Documentation Requests:
Another frustration that many Reddit users report is HireRight’s excessive documentation requests. While background checks are meant to verify specific information, HireRight has been accused of asking candidates for an unreasonable amount of documentation, especially when verifying employment history. Some users have reported being asked for tax documents, pay stubs, and employment records from businesses closed for years.
This can be problematic for small business owners because candidates who are already under pressure to provide these documents might become frustrated or even abandon the hiring process altogether. This extra burden on candidates can also lead to delays in completing the verification process.
Cost Concerns and Hidden Fees:
Despite HireRight’s initial appeal as a cost-effective option, some small businesses have reported unexpected increases in pricing over time. Reddit users have shared that their rates have increased by as much as 50% over a short period, raising questions about the service’s long-term affordability. This pricing inconsistency is a significant concern, as it could lead to unanticipated budget issues for small businesses trying to manage their costs.
Some users also mention hidden fees not initially disclosed, leading to frustrations when the final bill comes in higher than expected. This lack of transparency can cause problems for businesses relying on predictable budgeting and financial planning costs.
Verification Challenges:
The core purpose of any background check is to verify information, but HireRight has faced criticism for failing to adequately verify basic employment details. Users on Reddit report that HireRight struggled to confirm simple information like previous job titles, employment dates, or educational history. This inability to verify basic details leads to frustration and puts job candidates in the uncomfortable position of having to provide multiple forms of documentation to prove their qualifications.
This verification challenge raises a red flag for small businesses. Inaccurate or incomplete background checks could lead to the wrong candidates being hired or, worse, the potential loss of an ideal candidate due to verification delays.
The Cost Debate – Is Hireright Worth It?

Pricing Concerns for Small Businesses:
While HireRight markets itself as affordable, Reddit users have pointed out that the costs can escalate quickly. According to discussions on Reddit, the cost of a HireRight background check for a small business typically starts around $30-$40 per check for a basic package. More comprehensive packages, including additional checks like credit history or driving records, can reach upwards of $70 per check depending on the specific needs and state regulations. Reports of sudden rate hikes (up to 50%) raise concerns about its transparency and long-term value.
Key points from Reddit discussions about HireRight costs for small businesses:
- Package upgrades: For positions requiring more scrutiny, businesses can opt for more comprehensive packages with additional checks like employment verification, education verification, and drug testing.
- Variable pricing: The exact cost depends on the type of checks included in the package, the number of checks ordered, and the candidate’s location.
- Basic package affordability: A basic criminal background check is generally considered the most affordable option for small businesses.
Hidden Costs for Candidates:
The indirect costs of dealing with HireRight can be significant for job seekers. Time spent gathering outdated documents, responding to repeated requests, and enduring delays can lead to lost income and stalled career progress. Some candidates also report feeling frustrated by the constant back-and-forth, as they struggle to meet the company’s documentation demands. For those already juggling other job applications or commitments, these delays can feel like a major setback, making the hiring process even more stressful and time-consuming.
Let’s Take A Closer Look At How This Impacts Small Businesses:
For small businesses, the stakes are high. When it comes to hiring, small businesses can’t afford to waste time and resources on inefficient processes. Background checks are necessary, but if they are poorly executed or delayed, they can hinder a business’s ability to grow and succeed.
One primary concern is that delays in background checks might mean businesses lose top candidates with multiple job offers. Small businesses often operate on tight schedules and must fill positions quickly to avoid disrupting operations. If a candidate’s background check takes too long to process, that candidate might accept a job offer elsewhere, leaving the business in a difficult position.
Additionally, small businesses are particularly vulnerable to rising costs. If HireRight raises its prices without warning, companies could face significant budget strains. While the service might be affordable initially, these unpredictable price hikes can profoundly impact a small business’s bottom line.
What Does The Future Hold For Hireright? – Looking Ahead!
HireRight has its share of problems, particularly for small businesses that rely on affordable background checks to help streamline their hiring process. As user complaints surface on platforms like Reddit, HireRight may need to address these issues to remain competitive.

Businesses may seek alternatives if the company does not improve its processing times, reduce documentation requests, and maintain more consistent pricing. Other background check companies offering more efficient service, more explicit pricing, and fewer complications could begin gaining traction among small business owners looking for a more reliable solution.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do some small businesses choose HireRight despite negative reviews?
HireRight’s low cost makes it an attractive option for small businesses looking to manage hiring expenses. However, companies should consider potential drawbacks, such as delays and rising costs.
Is HireRight’s service reliable for background checks?
Many users report significant delays and difficulties with verification, which suggests that HireRight might not be the most reliable option for businesses needing quick and accurate background checks.
How can small businesses avoid hidden costs with HireRight?
Small businesses should ensure they are fully aware of all pricing details before signing up for HireRight’s services. Reviewing contracts and inquiring about any potential fee increases down the line is essential.
Why does HireRight ask for so much documentation?
HireRight often requests detailed documents like pay stubs, tax records, and employment contracts to ensure accuracy in their verification process. This approach is meant to meet compliance standards and verify hard-to-access information.
How long does a HireRight background check take?
The timeline for a HireRight background check varies but typically ranges from a few days to several weeks. Unfortunately, Reddit users often report delays far beyond the industry average, with some checks taking over a month.
Are there better alternatives to HireRight for small businesses?
Yes, many small businesses find alternatives like GoodHire, Checkr, or Sterling to be more user-friendly and efficient. These services offer similar features but often have better customer service and quicker processing times.
What should I do if my HireRight background check is delayed?
If your background check is delayed, contact your employer and keep them informed of the situation. Provide any requested documents promptly to avoid further delays, and consider contacting HireRight directly to expedite the process.
To Sum It All Up – Here’s What We’ve Learned!
Ultimately, HireRight’s small business cost may seem appealing initially, but its shortcomings in service quality and transparency have left many users dissatisfied. While the company offers affordable background checks, the long processing times, excessive documentation requests, and rising costs may outweigh the initial benefits for many small businesses.
The challenge for small businesses lies in balancing cost with quality. While affordability is crucial, efficiency and reliability are just as important. As small businesses continue to explore background check providers, they must carefully weigh the pros and cons of services like HireRight.
Also Read: